The Lord of the Rings Strategy Battle Game/Tactics/Minas Tirith

From 2d4chan
Revision as of 15:04, 4 December 2020 by 1d4chan>Ihateplotarmor
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Back to the list

Why Play Minas Tirith

Because Minas Tirith is one of the most complete LotR armies in the game, has some amazing models. These are your army if you want to be the Jack of all Trades army who have excellent defense values and AMAZING models. If anything these guys are kind of like your space marine analogues in that they are easy enough to paint, sturdier than your average man, and are the standard example of a 'good guy' in LotR.

Pros

  • Almost universally high Defense values
  • Incredibly versatile on the tabletop (Offensive, deffensive and mixed style)
  • Multiple amazing heroes
  • Has the ability to drop a metric TON of infantry down
  • despite low costs very strong statlines, able to pretty easily be as choppy and courageous as elves
  • TREBUCHETS!
  • You get to have Gandalf the Fucking White in your army! And Pippin OH YEAH...just kidding, ignore this dude as Denethor did.
  • Cheap army to get started into the game (plastic infantry/cavalry and elites are in blisters).

Cons

  • Not the best in any one field
  • Certain troops can be really expensive. To be fair, they are pretty well costed, so no "Extremely cheap for what they do in game" issue here...Go for elven armies if you look for bargains instead.
  • Heroes like Elessar/Uber Boromir must do the "heavy lifting" cause the entire infantry of this army has low killing power (Stuck at s3, no +1 to wound, hatred or s4 available unless you pick lances on your cavalry)

Army Bonus

All Gondor units increase their courage by 1, making most units courage 4 and Osgiliath Veterans Courage 5! this also gives heroes +1 courage making them even more resistant to terror.

Unit Analysis

Heroes

  • Aragorn, King Elessar: Much like his other versions, Aragorn is as great as ever. Arguably, he is THE BEST man-sized HERO available for the good forces in the entire game (100% Best good combat hero, even Jay Clare made him be the number 1 in his top 10 list and that list got the biggest hitters like Elendil, Dain, etc... ). Now toting a Defense of 7, Anduril base, and the option to take an Armoured horse (He is a horse lord so it is mandatory now) He's still the beatstick he always is, plus he counts as a 6" banner (including himself always). However, much like his other renditions, he is super expensive, nearly bordering on unplayable. At his current cost he shouldn't really be brought to any fight lower than 700 points, and even then you have some cheaper options rolling around.
  • Faramir, Captain of Gondor: One of those previously mentioned 'cheaper options.' To put it simply Faramir is amazing. at 80 points base and with a metric ton of upgrade options, Faramir can fill any role you need without issue. Factor in his slightly above standard statline and you have an amazing hero that will pull his weight, if not more, in any game you bring him in. With heavy armour, a shield, and a lance+horse you have a character who can smash through infantry, and still cost less than 100 points total. Generally speaking, if you want a solid (but cheap) hero, he's the go-to option. Be careful if you bring his daddy along as if you do, he has to charge an enemy unit if he is able to do so. Although this may not sound like much, if you are outnumbered and playing a defensive technique, his daddy issues will probably ruin your plan. Sadly, his new profile was not based on the best profile he got in the past (2010 Captain of Ithilien) compared to Shagrat, Azog or Éomer (who got the boosted profiles for the new version of the game) which hinders his killy/support capability to the army
  • Gandalf the White: One of the strongest supporting heroes in the game, with a flexible range of magical powers meaning that he will always be useful in nearly every situation - notable powers are Banishment, which lets you one-shot Ringwraiths; Sorcerous Blast to knock holes in the enemy lines; and of course the ever-awesome Blinding Light, which can hold your shieldwall safe from arrows or protect your cavalry on their way to the enemy. Add in base 6 Will points (plus a free one each turn from his Staff of Power), 3 Might, 3 Fate (which you can reroll thanks to the Elven ring that he carries around) and 2 attacks (3 if you charge whilst riding Shadowfax) that hit at strength 5, everyone’s favourite Jesus allegory is always a fantastic choice. It’s a shame that even all this doesn’t quite justify the fact that he’s 220 fucking points (without the horse). Save for larger games, then.
  • Peregrin, Guard of the Citadel: haha. no. Funnily enough, he's a defence 4 hobbit who's not even the cheapest hero available to you. to add insult to injury, he's an independent hero, meaning he can't even be brought to add on more troops. Worst choice for the army sadly, despite killing more orcs on screen than Irolas...
  • Boromir, Captain of the White Tower: The other super beat-stick character Minas Tirith can take. With almost as many options as Faramir, a solid Fight value and Defense of up to 7, he can and should be in your front line making a mess. What really puts him above other fighter heroes is his stupidly high Might value of 6, and the Horn of Gondor, which when you're outnumbered, can cause you to flat win the duel roll. It's worth noting that he can take the Banner of Minas Tirith, which is a 6" Banner that boosts his and friendly warriors fight value. Careful though, according to the FAQ, you can't take him alongside Aragorn, King Elessar and still hold on to your faction bonus or ability to ally. But he can be in the same army with Gandalf the White with no penalties...LOGIC
  • Madril, Captain of Ithilien:Here is where we get silly. Madril is a cheap ranger hero with an okay stat line, but it's his "Master of Ambush" rule that really makes him great. In short, he gives you a bonus to any and all rolls for reserves, so long as he is on the board. This includes rolls that happen later in the same turn, so if you want your men to come in on your terms, he's the guy to bring.
  • Damrod, Ranger of Ithilien: Damrod is a weird case. he has the absolute bog standard stat line with nothing really marking him out from the other heroes. that is until you see his laughable point cost of 25 points, i.e. one of the cheapest heroes on the good side of the isle, and he's almost an auto-include just for allowing you to put down more models. Bring him with 6 Rangers of Gondor for a small, cheap ranged warband - perfect for smaller point-values.
  • Denethor, Steward of Gondor: Denethor, like Damrod, is a weird case. he has an okay stat line (decent strength though), a high Courage, but no Might or fate. And while he may be 35 points, he has a special rule that risks him going acting as an evil model for a turn. He's able to bring along a metric ton of troops and if Boromir is in the same list, he no longer suffers from his madness special rule until Boromir falls. is Remember though, if you bring Denethor, he HAS to be your general unless you have Aragorn. NO EXCEPTIONS...He died in the movie before the crowning of Elessar and can be allied with the future king in game...AGAIN LOGIC. Given the solid number of troops he can have in his warband, Denethor works out very points effective. If you're already taking Boromir, he's an auto-include - otherwise, strongly consider bringing him for an absolute horde of silver knights.
  • Irolas: Average stat line but where he currently shines (his rules are currently beta) is his ability to shield (even though he doesn't have one) and if he wins the fight, he gets to make one attack allowing you to slowly chip away at enemy troops when he's surrounded. A dude with respectable f5 and def 6, capable of shielding despite not having shield and making a s4 strike (useful against horses/wargs) when shielding is AWESOME. He is worth the points.
  • Beregond: That one cool guy who said "fuck the rules" and saves our home-boy Faramir. With an Elf bow like the other citadel guard and the bodyguard rule (he's basically a guaranteed standfast), Beregrond acts as a solid support character, and much like Damrod, is below 30 points for that horde of silver men that you know you want to bring. Sadly, with the introduction of Heroic Tiers, your warband has been cut from 12 to just 6. Beregond is still worth it at low point values (makes for an excellent hero to pair with Rangers or Citadel Guard) but his sub-par stat-line limits his effectiveness against other heroes and even some of the more elite warriors, similarly to Damrod. Overall though, opens up a lot of options for MT.
  • Ingold: Rules are currently beta but his special rule makes the generic captain and a whole bunch of other heroes redundant. Despite having stats on par with a generic captain, he has one extra might point and D7 (making him D8 with shieldwall) all for 10 points more than a captain. But, his special rule is where he shines. All troops around him do not back away when they lose a fight, the enemy does! Although this may not seem like much, it will allow you to keep your front line in formation (keep the shieldwall!). Also if you attack over a wall and lose, congratulations, you now defend the wall! Sadly as per FAQ Ingold still counts as trapped if he can't theoretically back away- so no pike formation without ever being trapped.
  • Húrin the Tall: hero of valor, 3 might, F5 with heroic strike, a master-forged 2h sword, and a horse at only 90 points, this guy is looking strong right out the gates. better yet, he's fearless within 3" of elessar or denethor AND gets to reroll a d6 for his duel roll, meaning with Aragorn's banner rule he's got at least 4 shots to score a 6. top it off, as long as he's alive the enemy doesn't count for slaying your leader. If you're bringing Aragorn, he's a no-brainer.
  • Cirion, Lieutenant of Amon Barad: Cirion is basically a no-name lordling who is best described as a Captain of Minas Tirith who really wants to charge monsters. with his Courage 6 for the sake of charging things that cause terror, he seems like a good answer, until you remember he's only Strength 4 with no other special rules.
  • Knight of the White Tower:the first of the 'generic' heroes, and boy does he set a high standard. with 2 attacks, a high fight, and standard defense, he doesn't seem all that much, until you notice the rules for using his sword 2 handed, which cause each wound inflicted to double to 2 wounds, making him great at taking out non-hero monsters. He's basically everything Cirion wanted to be. Plus, if he gets a natural 6 when using the two handed weapon it stays as a 6!
  • Captain of Minas Tirith: The base option for our heroes. at 50 points with options for shields (autoinclude), bows, a lance and a horse, he can fill any roll you need him to. Made almost completely redundant by Ingold.
  • King of Men: A Captain +1. Seriously. he's a captain with 1 more fight, 1 more courage, and 1 more might and will, with the same options available to him. Be careful if you decide to take him as if you do, you cannot take any named heroes, limiting you to more Kings, captains and the Knights of the White tower. Little bit eh, but fairly pointed at least.

Troops

  • Warrior of Minas Tirith: your bread and butter unit. Criminally cheap Defense 6 units that have the Shieldwall special rule and with plenty of options to make them a bit more mobile they can easily pull their own weight and hold the line against some of the strongest enemy units. Their fight 3 is a bit of a worry against some armies (Isengard, Elves, Corsairs) so it's important to utilise your (likely) numbers advantage whenever you can. The shieldwall rule help keep your guys safe from bow-fire but it's always a good idea to keep some Guards of the Fountain Court or heroes on your flanks to stop your warbands from caving in. Planting your army between terrain pieces also help a lot.
  • Ranger of Gondor: Just like Warriors of Minas Tirith, these guys are there to fill a similar slot, albeit a more shooty variety, and with lower defence. They're not about to outshoot Elves or anything with crossbows but given the numbers you're likely to field, Rangers can dish out some pretty good damage against low-armour targets. Take some with Beregond in smaller-point games and take larger numbers with Madril in bigger-point games. Ignore the spears as Citadel Guards do the same job for the same price with a better defence and the bodyguard special rule. Not anymore, Citadel Guard have to swap their spears for bows while Rangers get them in addition, so rangers are now the superior option. Can be spammed in the Rangers of Ithilien Legendary Legion.
  • Citadel Guard: Time has not been kind to the poor ol' Guard. Taking these guys with longbows is now a whopping 10 points, which is a little pricey given Ranger of Gondor are not only cheaper but more accurate (and get to keep their spears). Hitting on 4's is pretty poor for an elite shooting unit, especially when compared with other armies ranged units. Elves (for just one more point) get a better shoot value, courage, fight value and their Elven-made weapons. Mounted, they're overpriced and weak to bows - in fact, they're weak to most warriors in general with your bog-standard KOMT boasting a higher defence (with shields) for way cheaper. Fight 4 is nice on a cavalry model but useless on a model that was sniped off his horse two-turns ago. Still, CG can plug gaps in your army. They can make decent support for your WOMT and the bodyguard ruled helps keep them on the table for longer if you break. In conclusion, Citadel Guard have slowly lost their versatility but they still shine in a few areas.
  • Guard of the Fountain Court: If the Citadel Guard is out second line of elite troops, these guys are your front line. With Defense 7 once you take a shield and spears base for 11 points, AND the same bodyguard rule as citadel guard, the only reason to not take some of these guys is if you're building a Fluff list. GotFC can easily be both a good support unit and frontline troops, often they'll end up doing both over the course of a game. Paired with a hero like Boromir or Aragorn, GFC can slap other warbands silly, especially if you give Boromir his banner which buffs them to the fight value of elves and generic heroes. Lean over and laugh breathlessly in your opponents face as they brush off bow-fire and slowly punch his fancy-painted minis to death. Not too much else to say, take them to anchor your larger warbands of basic units or on their own as a tough-to-kill deathstar with your stronger heroes. I have a huge problem with this profile, don't get me wrong he is amazing in game but it is related to his appearance in screen and equipment. First, in the movie they don't have shields and they were released in January 2004 without them so...why let him have it if he does not get it? Second, there are only four in Minas Tirith in the movie, yes you heard it yeah FOUR. They're supposed to be an UBER INFANTRY very limited, they do not appear in a single shot during the siege of Minas Tirith (Same applied to the citadel guard) So logically in the game...Nah SPAM THEM TO HAVE A METRIC TON OF POSSIBLE (Bannermir needed) f5 def 7 bodyguard infantry (WHY? ROHAN ROYAL GUARDS APPEAR IN DOZENS IN THE MOVIE SCENES, IT MAKES SENSE TO GET THEM AS A REGULAR UNIT). These guys, simply no. The game should have a rule to limit the amount of elites a list can take (they do limit the heroes choice with alliances to balance it) so it makes sense...(Like Ferekers army in previous edition or Sons of Eorl spam hahahahah seriously the THAT GUY SMELL...Third, his role in a Minas Tirith is like "I take you nearly exclusive in game def 7 warrior of Minas Tirith, ah and your shield and spear too. Hello citadel guard, I take your bodyguard special rule and your base fight 4...You know what I mean...The should get a specific niche in the army (No shield in movie and the GW model, having a long spear and base def 6...PIKES should have been their fix and niche addition to the Mianas Tirith list). Minas Tirith has a wide selection of trrops that get a niche (good archer and cheap f4...rangers, solid def 6/7...warrior of Minas Tirith, heavy cavalry...knight of Minas Tirith, elite cavalry that can skirmish...citadel guard on horseback, elite spear/archer and bodyguard...citadel guard, dudes that get jedi skill near two great heroes (and brothers) and more valiant in the list...veterans of Osgiliath. Fountain court is redundant because it takes things from other profiles, mix them and you get a superb profile, but very repetitive. (Def base 6 troops without shield is a huge premium in non dwarven-armies...why def 7? Better a pike instead of shield, that would make them AWESOME AS THEY ARE NOW BUT WITH A COHERENT EQUIPMENT AND A DIFFERENT ROLE IN THE ARMY) Sorry if my opinion is not like yours, but I don't understand the GW logic for this profile. Anyway, the profile is arguably the best infantry available for the armies of men in the game for sure, so I understand that you prefer the current profile.
  • Osgiliath Veteran: Outside of fluff, these guys aren't really worth it. 1+ courage is nice but not always necessary and since 2 out of 4 of your basic infantry units already have the bodyguard special rule, you're probably not short on high-courage units already, especially given Minas Tirith's army bonus. Bows aren't worth it at all given the Rangers of Gondor are cheaper and have a better shoot value. Their special rule is excellent for the vets themselves but can leave Boromir and Faramir away from the thickest of the fighting - also known as exactly where they're usually played. You're pretty likely to end up wasting points on the two previously mentioned heroes if you keep them on the sidelines specifically just to buff the warband they're with. Remember, once they're 6" away from the two, expensive named heroes, Osgiliath Veterans are no better in combat than normal WOMT. Now, with all that being said, Osgiliath Veterans can still be a way (note: not a good, easy to use way) of getting fight 5 on the table when taken with Boromir and his Banner of Minas Tirith. A small warband accompanying Boromir can do nearly as well as Fountain Court Guard for slightly cheaper. Taking a small warband with Faramir is also an option in smaller-point games. Overall, not a great unit but you do have a couple options and shit, at least they aren't Morgal Stalkers!

Cavalry

  • Knight of Minas Tirith: Basically a Warrior on a horse with a lance. just like the warrior he can take a shield for Defense 6 (Mandatory). If you want faster Warriors to run with a horse hero, these are your first choice. Very versatile near Elessar and extremely good near Uber Boromir with the banner...
  • Citadel Guard: Read the above.

Artillery

  • Battlecry Trebuchet: Who needs rings of power when you can launch a 90Kg stone over 300 meters? at 110 points, you get a terrifying weapon that absolutely devastate whatever it hits, and even does a fair bit of damage to things standing to close to its target. With a slew of upgrades, it's a really fun weapon to use in larger games, however it is too expensive for lower point matches.
  • Avenger Bolt Thrower: Who knew that Minas Tirith had Maxim Guns? At 50 points, you will be grabbing swift reload for 20 points so you roll 2D6 and choose the highest for shooting. Siege vet gives it a might point. Oh, and it no longer scatters. You read that right, its shots no longer scatter making this weapon a S7 sniper that will be causing wounds on a 3+ on all but the toughest enemy models. This machine is now a must have and if you feel like being mean in your next tournament, take 2 of them. If the designer of the new profiles loses to this toy in the next tournaments, it will be massively nerfed to be unplayable (THAT'S HOW IT IS TREATED THE GAME NOW SADLY). SMAUG IS TERRIFIED OF THIS MACHINE. Remember if he gets a wound he suffers equal number of wounds to the strength of the weapon used so...Strength 7=7 seven wounds per wound inflicted and if you can shoot d6 times each turn...YOU CAN ONE SHOT HIM IN A SINGLE TURN OF SHOOTING...OMG

Allies

Historical Allies

The Fiefdoms

Rohan

The Dead of Dunharrow

Fangorn

Convenient Allies

The Fellowship

Rivendell

Thranduil's Hall

Lothlorien

Impossible Allies

Arnor

Numenor

The Kingdom of Khazad-Dum

The Shire

The Misty Mountains

The Wanderers in the Wild

Thorin's Company

Radagast's Alliance

Army of Thror

Garrison of Dale

The White Council

Army of Laketown

Survivors of Laketown

Iron Hills Dwarves

Erebor Reclaimed

Building your Army

Much like the other armies in the game, starting a Minas Tirith army is cheap: a box of warriors and your choice of hero ends up costing $40 and sitting at around 200 points depending on your choices, and from there your options are endless. the next steps for a generic force would be getting a few bow armed citadel guard and Guards of the Fountain Court to start diving into the more elite units, if not another box of Warriors of Minas Tirith. It's worth noting that the bow-armed Warriors from the box are not the best and while they are a decent starting point, should probably be phased out relatively quickly.

Tactics

Where to begin with Minas Tirith? Firstly, do not forget Shieldwall. This special rule gives you a reason to take Warriors of Minas Tirith to game other than for fluff. The D7 wall is tough to smash through for all but the luckiest of attacks and is one of the two anvils that you can create for the age-old 'hammer anvil tactic'

In all seriousness, when looking through the Minas Tirith list you will notice that you have a huge number of heroes to pick from. Although this may seem great, it is only great on paper. Minas Tirith suffers from option paralysis. That being, nearly every single hero is great in some way that can make a huge difference in almost any game, but ultimately, you will struggle to actually make your list.

The most common tactic for Gondor is the one mentioned earlier, the Hammer Anvil tactic. This is where your front line holds the enemy in place and keeps them in place while something else in your army destroys the enemies flank and then swings around to flank/rear charge your enemy, securing a hard won victory. If you are going to use this tactic, two of your troop choices shine for the frontline of your anvil. These troops are the Warriors of Minas Tirith and the Fountain Guard. Fountain Guard are slightly more expensive BUT oh boy are they worth it. Keep the Hero they are bodyguarding alive and they can charge and hold down units that cause terror while only falling to the luckiest of strikes. Even better, their fight is captain level so they will be winning the majority of fights and striking to kill. Although their strength is average, they should be able to do some damage before the hammer swings around. If you feel like being mean, bring Boromir Captain of the White Tower with the banner to lead them. Their fight goes up to elf level meaning you will be winning or drawing fights against nearly 75% of all units in this game system while Boromir can draw against a Troll. The other group of troops you can take for the anvil is Warriors of Minas Tirith. The Shieldwall special rule means that so long as they are together they are D7 but their fight is very average. To fix this, have them supported by Citidel Guard who are slightly cheaper than Fountain Court but they do have a lower defense, and no option for a shield. If you decide to take Warriors of Minas Tirith for your line, be sure to bring Ingold to lead them. His special rule means that even if you lose you're standing still (great for holding objectives) while you have to do less tricks to keep your Shieldwall for so long. Now for your hammer, unless you have allies, it will be Knights of Minas Tirith as you want to get into combat ASAP. A good leader for them is Faramir due to the number of options he has, while another choice is potentially Boromir with the banner. Making your Knights F4 means that they'll be able to effectively win most fights while Boromir will ensure that any troll or monster on the flank is quickly dealt with.

The other tactic that can be used, depending on how many friends you feel like losing, is the 'Shooting Anvil' tactic. This being, in your 'Anvil' insert 2 or even 3 Avenger Bolt Throwers, sit back, and shoot your enemy to oblivion. Then, as the enemy gets close, pull them out of the line and set them to the side with some 'elite' troops to protect them along with a hero that cannot be ignored. Your opponent will be forced to decide between destroying the Bolt Throwers or your anvil. The Bolt Throwers should last long enough for the anvil to come to assistance or your enemy will completely ignore them and have its rear shot to bits. Three Avengers and a few troops to look after them will cost around 300 points and a hero will put it up to 380ish points, making it very worthwhile. Furthermore remember, siege engines deploy touching the board edge so you should get 3-5 turns of decent shooting out of them, averaging around 6 kills per turn. Although this may not seem like much, over 3 turns you could cause 18 odd casualties. This number, in a game system where numbers count and most armies average between 30-50 models, means you can break your enemy before they get into combat with you. This tactic, however, is not workable in games where you need to grab an objective or where troops randomly enter the board.

A point of weakness with Gondor. If you're going up against a magic heavy army, you will struggle. Many heroes of Minas Tirith only have a single point of Will, so it won't take much for your opponent to start paralyzing your heroes or knocking down your entire front line with Tremour or Sorcerous Blast. A solution to this is Pippin as he has the resistant to magic special rule, meaning that you will always be getting a single dice to resist the effects of the spell if Pippin is in range of it (It may not seem like much, but with his Elven Cloak Pippin can be good to hold an objective in terrain behind your main line in other games) Denethor is also a good source of cheap Will.

However, one of the best things about Minas Tirith is their army has a counter to nearly everything. Facing an opponent with lots of shooting? Gandalf the White and blinding light. Enemy outnumbers you? Avenger Bolt Throwers/Trebuchet. Playing a scenario where reinforcements are a thing? Madril will get them to the field. Want to go crazy with a kickass hero but you don't want your opponent to gain victory points in case you roll really badly once? Denethor is the solution. Assaulting an enemy who is defending barricades? Ingold will lead the way. The enemy army is scary? Anything with bodyguard. The only problem with this is that you cannot cater your list to every enemy army that you go up against in a tournament, but you can build the jack of all trades lists as follows:

      1. Grab a kickass general. Aragorn, Boromir and Gandalf are fantastic choices. Each can bring a ton of troops and each of them can tear through enemy troops like there is no tomorrow (Gandalf is a slight exception to this) meaning that you will have a decent chance of winning games where hero-kill count is important. 
      2. Grab a good supporting Hero. If you want to bring more troops, grab Denethor who is cheap and can bring a bunch of men (great hero too when Boromir is brought as well) if you want to ensure that your enemy doesn't get victory points for killing your kickass hero? Denethor and/or Húrin (bringing both is a massive troll move, however) Keep Denethor back or if you have Boromir, keep him nearby and if either (or both) falls run Húrin away and laugh as your opponent realizes that they get 0 points for killing your general. Bringing Denethor however, means you will struggle to win general kill count games. Want another decent hero to lead your knights into battle? Faramir is the way to go due to the number of options he has and due to his decent stat line. 
      3. Grab Madril. Most tournaments will have a scenario where reinforcements are a thing. Madril ensures a 2/3 chance of bringing your troops in on the same board edge. Get a 1? Keep it. Get a 2? 1 might or put it down to 1. Get a 3? It's now a 4. This may seem like a waste but remember he also has Woodland Creature, so he can grab an objective and go hide where you need him too while being able to protect himself better than Pippin. Although it may be only 1 game in the tournament, that 1 game can be the difference between coming in the top 3 or the top 10 (and there is nothing better than surrounding an enemy Warband or two while the rest of the enemy army is off the board or on the other side of it) 
      4. Take a Avenger Bolt Thrower. This sniper will kill many heroes who are leading the front line while also dealing damage to enemy monsters who will mess up your battle line. Want to lose friends? Take 2. Want to get kicked out of the gaming club/tournament? Bring 3 and ensure you have a lot of spare crewmen. 
      5. Your anvil must either be Fountain Guard or Warriors of Minas Tirith. Either one is good enough. Osgilith Veterans are only good for themed lists, although their loyal to their captain special rule is pretty good, they don't have shieldwall neither do they gain any bouns from fighting in ruins (which considering the fact that they have been fighting in a ruined city, its a surprise that they don't get any special bonus) 
      6. When deciding what others heroes to take, cater them and their warband to a specific role. Monster and hero hunting? Knight of the White Tower and some Fountain Guard (Aragon and Boromir may be fantastic, but don't think they're immune. Rend will mess them up and they are arrow/magic magnets) Strike with him, ensure the monster is trapped and laugh as it falls. Want a character who can take on units with Blades of the Dead? Cirion. Army bonus combined with his special rule means blades of the dead is wounding on a 6. Want a hero to lead the assault on fortified positions/hold a position/shieldwall? Ingold is the way to go. Want a sacrifice hero who will draw attention and win most fights? Irolas will win most fights and will probably do a few kills and generally annoy and hold the enemy up. 
      7. Do. Not. Think. You. Can. Run. A. All. Hero. Army. List. This isn't Thorins Company where their special rules actually means that you are a 12 dwarf (and one hobbit and wizard) army. You will need troops to hold the line and fire weapons of war. Fill up your warbands to at least half their capacity and don't be afraid to max out a few warbands. If you have 100 odd points to spare, grab Damrod or Beregond. If Damrod, grab what you are lacking. If Beregond, give him a horse and some knights (or citidel guardsmen on horses) Only grab a couple of extra heroes if you are lacking in them and if you have enough bodies for the meat grinder.

If you follow this army building guide, you should have fun with it and win a few games. Remember though, if you're playing a friendly game, want to win best painted or want it to be like the movies, make a themed army list. You can easily do this and many people will enjoy playing against you. Most importantly, have fun, thats the real point of the game. Unless you play at 500 points or below and choose the Faramir's rangers legendary legion where you can field YOUR ENTIRE ARMY WITH BOWS. YES YOU CAN. Considering that you could field between 30-35 models and have some sneaky special rules related to the heroes in this legion, it is arguably the shootiest list in Middle Earth SBG. Try to have fun against that.