Sha'ir: Difference between revisions

From 2d4chan
Jump to navigation Jump to search
1d4chan>QuietBrowser
(Finally got my hands on Dragon #315, so could add a little to the 3.5 version.)
1d4chan>QuietBrowser
(Added 4th edition Sha'ir outline.)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Dnd-stub}}
[[File:genie.gif|thumb|right|Jihadi [[Why Djinns Suck|Djinn]] ]]
[[File:genie.gif|thumb|right|Jihadi [[Why Djinns Suck|Djinn]] ]]
The '''Sha'ir''' of [[Al-Qadim]] are an odd sub-type of generally charisma based [[Wizard]]s, introduced in the Arabian Adventures splatbook for [[Advanced Dungeons & Dragons|d&d 2e]] and fleshed out more thoroughly in The Complete Sha'ir's Handbook; they were then republished as a full class in [[Dragon Magazine]] number 315 for 3e. They play as a sort of wizard-sorcerer hybrid, or a [[warlock]] if you're looking at them with 5e eyes. The [[4th Edition Dungeons and Dragons|4th edition]] rules can be found in Heroes of the Elemental Chaos.
The '''Sha'ir''' of [[Al-Qadim]] are an odd sub-type of generally charisma based [[Wizard]]s, introduced in the Arabian Adventures splatbook for [[Advanced Dungeons & Dragons|d&d 2e]] and fleshed out more thoroughly in The Complete Sha'ir's Handbook; they were then republished as a full class in [[Dragon Magazine]] number 315 for 3e. They play as a sort of wizard-sorcerer hybrid, or a [[warlock]] if you're looking at them with 5e eyes. The [[4th Edition Dungeons and Dragons|4th edition]] rules can be found in Heroes of the Elemental Chaos.
Line 5: Line 4:
Fluff wise, sha'irs are wizards who partner up with a lesser [[genie]], called a "gen", to work their magic. In essence, the gen works a sort of hybrid between a [[familiar]] and a stock broker; rather than having conventional spellbooks or memorizing spells themselves, a sha'ir tells their gen what spell they want to cast and then it goes zipping off into the Elemental Planes to try and "find it". For one gen, this may entail acquiring a charged magical token produced on the Elemental Planes that can be tapped into to unleash that specific spell, whilst another gen may soak up enough raw elemental magic to become a temporary "living spellscroll" for its sha'ir. As a result, sha'irs have a much larger spell list than normal wizards, and can even use divine spells.
Fluff wise, sha'irs are wizards who partner up with a lesser [[genie]], called a "gen", to work their magic. In essence, the gen works a sort of hybrid between a [[familiar]] and a stock broker; rather than having conventional spellbooks or memorizing spells themselves, a sha'ir tells their gen what spell they want to cast and then it goes zipping off into the Elemental Planes to try and "find it". For one gen, this may entail acquiring a charged magical token produced on the Elemental Planes that can be tapped into to unleash that specific spell, whilst another gen may soak up enough raw elemental magic to become a temporary "living spellscroll" for its sha'ir. As a result, sha'irs have a much larger spell list than normal wizards, and can even use divine spells.


In 2e, sha'ir competency is counterbalanced by several things. Firstly, because all of the power comes from the gen, a sha'ir can only have '''one''' spell to hand at a time, and then their gen has to go and find another spell. Secondly, a gen can only hold the power for a spell for three turns, after which it loses the spell whether it was cast or not. Thirdly, retrieving a spell takes time (1d6+level of the spell); this ranges from rounds ("native" spells) to turns ("universal" spells) to ''hours'' (priest spells, foreign wizard spells) -- this is, needless to say, problematic if you're in the middle of a fight. Fourthly, gens never have more than an 89% chance of retrieving the spell asked for, meaning all that time may be ultimately wasted. Fifthly, stealing priestly spells via gen may result in divine punishment, which can range from a short-lived bad luck curse to being summoned to an offended god's realm for a personal audience. Finally, as the sources of a sha'ir's powers, gens are much more high-maintenance than standard familiars; they will direct their masters on personal quests, need time off to sleep and cement bonds with other elementals in order to be at full power, expect praise, and demand a monthly wage to reinforce that they are ''partners'' and '''not''' ''slaves''. Failure to treat a gen as it expects will cause it to grow increasingly unreliable as it rebels against such cruelty, concluding in it summoning a bigger, nastier, high ranked genie as an arbitrator to ''force'' a conclusion, whether that be a sincere restitution or a permanent dissolution of their contract.
Ironically, according to the other wiki, sha'ir [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sha'ir were pre-Islamic desert wandering poet-oracles in real life.] Multiclass [[Bard]], then?
 
Like most of the content in the Al-Qadim sourcebooks, it's been left to wither on the vine for the past 20 years due to sensitivity towards all things Arab. An update for 5e taking into account the modern geopolitics of the area, including magical artillery blowing up ancient sites and a theologically driven uprising, would be both hilarious and generate ''phenomenal'' amounts of butthurt. ISIS should be your next campaign setting.
 
==AD&D==
In 2e, sha'ir competency is counterbalanced by several things.
 
Firstly, because all of the power comes from the gen, a sha'ir can only have '''one''' spell to hand at a time, and then their gen has to go and find another spell.
 
Secondly, a gen can only hold the power for a spell for three turns, after which it loses the spell whether it was cast or not. Thirdly, retrieving a spell takes time (1d6+level of the spell); this ranges from rounds ("native" spells) to turns ("universal" spells) to ''hours'' (priest spells, foreign wizard spells) -- this is, needless to say, problematic if you're in the middle of a fight.
 
Fourthly, gens never have more than an 89% chance of retrieving the spell asked for, meaning all that time may be ultimately wasted.
 
Fifthly, stealing priestly spells via gen may result in divine punishment, which can range from a short-lived bad luck curse to being summoned to an offended god's realm for a personal audience.
 
Finally, as the sources of a sha'ir's powers, gens are much more high-maintenance than standard familiars; they will direct their masters on personal quests, need time off to sleep and cement bonds with other elementals in order to be at full power, expect praise, and demand a monthly wage to reinforce that they are ''partners'' and '''not''' ''slaves''. Failure to treat a gen as it expects will cause it to grow increasingly unreliable as it rebels against such cruelty, concluding in it summoning a bigger, nastier, high ranked genie as an arbitrator to ''force'' a conclusion, whether that be a sincere restitution or a permanent dissolution of their contract.
 
==3e===
In 3e, things are simplified, turning the class into a Charisma-based Wizard. They gain access to a small number of "spells known", which are easier for their gen to retrieve, and retrieving spells essentially replaces the usual wizard mechanic of studying; they don't keep their spells forever, but they don't need to summon a spell directly beforehand either.
 
Retrieving a spell is based on a DC 20 Diplomacy (Charisma) check, modified favorably by the sha'ir's own level and unfavorably by spell level, if it's a divine spell, metamagic boosts, and if they screwed up a "barter roll" for the same spell earlier.
 
Depending on how well you rolled your stats, they could be '''hilariously''' overpowered, with the ability to cast any spell (like a wizard) at any time (like a sorcerer).
 
They don't get access to all [[Cleric]] spells in this edition either, just the "domain spells" from the [[Cleric Domain]]s of Air, Chaos, Earth, Fire, Knowledge, Law, Luck, Sun, and Water.
 
==4e==
In 4th edition, Sha'irs are presented as variant to the [[Wizard]] class - yes, they probably could have gotten away with reflavoring the [[Warlock]], but they decided to just make a more [[Archomental]]-themed pact for them. 4e Sha'irs are Arcane Controllers keying off of [[Intelligence]] and [[Constitution]]; they're essentially the same as [[Wizard]]s, but trade the Arcane Implement Mastery, Ritual Casting and Spellbook features for Gen Servant and Elemental Resistance.


In 3e, things are simplified, turning the class into a Charisma-based Wizard. They gain access to a small number of "spells known", which are easier for their gen to retrieve, and retrieving spells essentially replaces the usual wizard mechanic of studying; they don't keep their spells forever, but they don't need to summon a spell directly beforehand either. Retrieving a spell is based on a DC 20 Diplomacy (Charisma) check, modified favorably by the sha'ir's own level and unfavorably by spell level, if it's a divine spell, metamagic boosts, and if they screwed up a "barter roll" for the same spell earlier. Depending on how well you rolled your stats, they could be *hilariously* overpowered, with the ability to cast any spell (like a wizard) at any time (like a sorcerer). They don't get access to all Cleric spells in this edition either, just the "domain spells" from the domains of Air, Chaos, Earth, Fire, Knowledge, Law, Luck, Sun, and Water.
Gen Servant grants them a [[Familiar]] for free, and actually makes Sha'irs a little more open to refluffing; whilst the traditional "minor genies" are presented as new familiars (Daolanin, Djinnling, Efreetkin, Maridan), the Sha'ir can take any other familiar instead whilst still functioning.


Ironically, according to the other wiki, sha'ir [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sha'ir were pre-Islamic desert wandering poet-oracles in real life.] Multiclass [[Bard]], then?
Elemental Resistance lets a Sha'ir gain [[Damage Reduction]] to Acid, Cold, Fire, Lightning and Thunder damage - specifically, they choose which damage type to resist at the end of each extended rest, and they gain Elemental Resistance equal to their Constitution modifier (double that, from level 21 on) when standing adjacent to their familiar in Active mode. The bright side is that the Sha'ir's allies also benefit from this Elemental Resistance if they're standing adjacent to the Sha'ir's familiar.


Like most of the content in the Al-Qadim sourcebooks, it's been left to wither on the vine for the past 20 years due to sensitivity towards all things Arab. An update for 5e taking into account the modern geopolitics of the area, including magical artillery blowing up ancient sites and a theologically driven uprising, would be both hilarious and generate ''phenomenal'' amounts of butthurt. ISIS should be your next campaign setting.
Aside from those core mechanic tweaks, Sha'irs are literally just wizards. That's it. Even [[Bladesinger]]s had more complex rules than them. Not that this is necessarily a bad thing.


{{D&D3-Classes}}
{{D&D3-Classes}}
{{D&D4-Classes}}
{{D&D4-Classes}}

Revision as of 03:11, 29 November 2017

Jihadi Djinn

The Sha'ir of Al-Qadim are an odd sub-type of generally charisma based Wizards, introduced in the Arabian Adventures splatbook for d&d 2e and fleshed out more thoroughly in The Complete Sha'ir's Handbook; they were then republished as a full class in Dragon Magazine number 315 for 3e. They play as a sort of wizard-sorcerer hybrid, or a warlock if you're looking at them with 5e eyes. The 4th edition rules can be found in Heroes of the Elemental Chaos.

Fluff wise, sha'irs are wizards who partner up with a lesser genie, called a "gen", to work their magic. In essence, the gen works a sort of hybrid between a familiar and a stock broker; rather than having conventional spellbooks or memorizing spells themselves, a sha'ir tells their gen what spell they want to cast and then it goes zipping off into the Elemental Planes to try and "find it". For one gen, this may entail acquiring a charged magical token produced on the Elemental Planes that can be tapped into to unleash that specific spell, whilst another gen may soak up enough raw elemental magic to become a temporary "living spellscroll" for its sha'ir. As a result, sha'irs have a much larger spell list than normal wizards, and can even use divine spells.

Ironically, according to the other wiki, sha'ir were pre-Islamic desert wandering poet-oracles in real life. Multiclass Bard, then?

Like most of the content in the Al-Qadim sourcebooks, it's been left to wither on the vine for the past 20 years due to sensitivity towards all things Arab. An update for 5e taking into account the modern geopolitics of the area, including magical artillery blowing up ancient sites and a theologically driven uprising, would be both hilarious and generate phenomenal amounts of butthurt. ISIS should be your next campaign setting.

AD&D

In 2e, sha'ir competency is counterbalanced by several things.

Firstly, because all of the power comes from the gen, a sha'ir can only have one spell to hand at a time, and then their gen has to go and find another spell.

Secondly, a gen can only hold the power for a spell for three turns, after which it loses the spell whether it was cast or not. Thirdly, retrieving a spell takes time (1d6+level of the spell); this ranges from rounds ("native" spells) to turns ("universal" spells) to hours (priest spells, foreign wizard spells) -- this is, needless to say, problematic if you're in the middle of a fight.

Fourthly, gens never have more than an 89% chance of retrieving the spell asked for, meaning all that time may be ultimately wasted.

Fifthly, stealing priestly spells via gen may result in divine punishment, which can range from a short-lived bad luck curse to being summoned to an offended god's realm for a personal audience.

Finally, as the sources of a sha'ir's powers, gens are much more high-maintenance than standard familiars; they will direct their masters on personal quests, need time off to sleep and cement bonds with other elementals in order to be at full power, expect praise, and demand a monthly wage to reinforce that they are partners and not slaves. Failure to treat a gen as it expects will cause it to grow increasingly unreliable as it rebels against such cruelty, concluding in it summoning a bigger, nastier, high ranked genie as an arbitrator to force a conclusion, whether that be a sincere restitution or a permanent dissolution of their contract.

3e=

In 3e, things are simplified, turning the class into a Charisma-based Wizard. They gain access to a small number of "spells known", which are easier for their gen to retrieve, and retrieving spells essentially replaces the usual wizard mechanic of studying; they don't keep their spells forever, but they don't need to summon a spell directly beforehand either.

Retrieving a spell is based on a DC 20 Diplomacy (Charisma) check, modified favorably by the sha'ir's own level and unfavorably by spell level, if it's a divine spell, metamagic boosts, and if they screwed up a "barter roll" for the same spell earlier.

Depending on how well you rolled your stats, they could be hilariously overpowered, with the ability to cast any spell (like a wizard) at any time (like a sorcerer).

They don't get access to all Cleric spells in this edition either, just the "domain spells" from the Cleric Domains of Air, Chaos, Earth, Fire, Knowledge, Law, Luck, Sun, and Water.

4e

In 4th edition, Sha'irs are presented as variant to the Wizard class - yes, they probably could have gotten away with reflavoring the Warlock, but they decided to just make a more Archomental-themed pact for them. 4e Sha'irs are Arcane Controllers keying off of Intelligence and Constitution; they're essentially the same as Wizards, but trade the Arcane Implement Mastery, Ritual Casting and Spellbook features for Gen Servant and Elemental Resistance.

Gen Servant grants them a Familiar for free, and actually makes Sha'irs a little more open to refluffing; whilst the traditional "minor genies" are presented as new familiars (Daolanin, Djinnling, Efreetkin, Maridan), the Sha'ir can take any other familiar instead whilst still functioning.

Elemental Resistance lets a Sha'ir gain Damage Reduction to Acid, Cold, Fire, Lightning and Thunder damage - specifically, they choose which damage type to resist at the end of each extended rest, and they gain Elemental Resistance equal to their Constitution modifier (double that, from level 21 on) when standing adjacent to their familiar in Active mode. The bright side is that the Sha'ir's allies also benefit from this Elemental Resistance if they're standing adjacent to the Sha'ir's familiar.

Aside from those core mechanic tweaks, Sha'irs are literally just wizards. That's it. Even Bladesingers had more complex rules than them. Not that this is necessarily a bad thing.

Dungeons & Dragons 3rd Edition classes
Player's Handbook BarbarianBardClericDruidFighterMonkPaladinRangerRogueSorcererWizard
Player's Handbook II BeguilerDragon ShamanDuskbladeKnight
Complete Adventurer ExemplarNinjaScoutSpellthief
Complete Arcane WarlockWarmageWu jen
Complete Divine Favored SoulShugenjaSpirit Shaman
Complete Psionic ArdentDivine MindEruditeLurk
Complete Warrior HexbladeSamuraiSwashbuckler
Dragon Compendium Battle DancerDeath MasterJesterMountebankSavantSha'irUrban Druid
Dragon Magazine Sha'ir
Dragon Magic Dragonfire Adept
Dungeonscape Factotum
Eberron Campaign Setting Artificer
Heroes of Horror ArchivistDread Necromancer
Magic of Incarnum IncarnateSoulbornTotemist
Miniatures Handbook Favored SoulHealerMarshalWarmage
Ghostwalk Eidolon (Eidoloncer)
Oriental Adventures SamuraiShamanShugenjaSoheiWu Jen
Psionics Handbook PsionPsychic WarriorSoulknifeWilder
Tome of Battle CrusaderSwordsageWarblade
Tome of Magic BinderShadowcasterTruenamer
War of the Lance Master
Wizards's Website Psychic Rogue
NPC Classes AdeptAristocratCommonerExpertMagewrightWarrior
Second Party MarinerMysticNobleProphet
Class-related things Epic LevelsFavored ClassGestalt characterMulticlassingPrestige ClassRacial Paragon ClassTier SystemVariant Class
Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition Classes
Player's Handbook 1 ClericFighterPaladinRangerRogueWarlockWarlordWizard
Player's Handbook 2 AvengerBarbarianBardDruidInvokerShamanSorcererWarden
Player's Handbook 3 ArdentBattlemindMonkPsionRunepriestSeeker
Heroes of X Blackguard* • Binder* • Cavalier* • Elementalist* • Hexblade* • Hunter* • Mage* • Knight* • Protector* • Scout* • Sentinel* • Skald* • Slayer* • Sha'ir* • Thief* • Vampire* • Warpriest* • Witch*
Settings Book ArtificerBladesinger* • Swordmage
Dragon Magazine Assassin
Others Paragon PathEpic Destiny
*·: Non-AEDU variant classes