M551 Sheridan: Difference between revisions

From 2d4chan
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 26: Line 26:
This however got them into a pinch: having switched to the MBT doctrine and already pouring massive budget in the MBT-70 project (another can of worms best left opened for another day and place), the Army simply could not ask for more budget for yet another tank. So they [[Rules lawyer|elegantly reclassified]] the new project as an "Armored Reconnaissance/Airborne Assault Vehicle" instead, and pushed it through with the alluring sales pitch the vehicle would be [[awesome|lightweight, amphibious, air-droppable, and able to use both state-of-the-art caseless munitions and ATGMs]]. In theory, the perfect lightweight jack-of-all-trades to support the bigger full-fledged tanks currently in development.
This however got them into a pinch: having switched to the MBT doctrine and already pouring massive budget in the MBT-70 project (another can of worms best left opened for another day and place), the Army simply could not ask for more budget for yet another tank. So they [[Rules lawyer|elegantly reclassified]] the new project as an "Armored Reconnaissance/Airborne Assault Vehicle" instead, and pushed it through with the alluring sales pitch the vehicle would be [[awesome|lightweight, amphibious, air-droppable, and able to use both state-of-the-art caseless munitions and ATGMs]]. In theory, the perfect lightweight jack-of-all-trades to support the bigger full-fledged tanks currently in development.


Sadly enough, in practice the Sheridan turned out to be a [[FAIL|complete and utter master-of-none]]. It was air-droppable and amphibious, yes, and its light structure made it less at risk to bog down or throw tracks than his bigger M48 and M60 cousins. But for the rest. Nothing. Worked. As. Intended! The worst offender was the ''Shillelagh'' ATGM: the Army's performance demands from Ford Aerospace for the missile circa 1963 were audacious--too audacious for 1960s or 1970s technology, not if it was going to be mass produced. Part of the problem was that due to limitations of the guidance system, designed in the 1960s, a ''Shillelagh'' ATGM could not be fired at closer than 730 meters, held by some to be greater than the distance to which the main gun could be fired with any accuracy. It took that long to stabilize and begin accepting guidance input from the gunner. Worse, the tank might have been air-droppableb but the ATGM's themselves [[FAIL|weren't]], as the solid rocket fuel tended to crack during drop testing. To compound problems further, the 152mm gun/launcher was such a high caliber for the Sheridan's overall size that every time it fired the vehicle bucked backward and all the fucking electronics had to go through a full reboot, making switching from HE shells to ATGM's a pain. (It is sad/hilarious that of the over 80.000 produced ATGM's, no more than a dozen were ever fired at a real enemy over the entire lifespan of the M551.)
Sadly enough, in practice the Sheridan turned out to be a [[FAIL|complete and utter master-of-none]]. It was air-droppable and amphibious, yes, and its light structure made it less at risk to bog down or throw tracks than his bigger M48 and M60 cousins. But for the rest. Nothing. Worked. As. Intended! The worst offender was the ''Shillelagh'' ATGM: the Army's performance demands from Ford Aerospace for the missile circa 1963 were audacious--too audacious for 1960s or 1970s technology, not if it was going to be mass produced. Part of the problem was that due to limitations of the guidance system, designed in the 1960s, a ''Shillelagh'' ATGM could not be fired at closer than 730 meters, held by some to be greater than the distance to which the main gun could be fired with any accuracy. It took that long to stabilize and begin accepting guidance input from the gunner. Worse, the tank might have been air-droppable but the ATGM's themselves [[FAIL|weren't]], as the solid rocket fuel tended to crack during drop testing. To compound problems further, the 152mm gun/launcher was such a high caliber for the Sheridan's overall size that every time it fired the vehicle bucked backward and all the fucking electronics had to go through a full reboot, making switching from HE shells to ATGM's a pain. (It is sad/hilarious that of the over 80.000 produced ATGM's, no more than a dozen were ever fired at a real enemy over the entire lifespan of the M551.)


Thus, with the end result buggier than an iPhone the Sheridans in Vietnam simply weren't issued any ATGMs, limiting them to chuck their caseless HE at footsloggers. The 152mm gun did have an antipersonnel flechette round available late in the war, and records of its use in Cambodia make it sound [[rape|highly effective]]. But, while the infantry loved the Sheridan for its direct-fire support, the lack of a working AT ammunition got them [[rape|REKT]] in turn when the northern commies sent proper MBT's into the dance. This proved to be the beginning of the end for the Sheridan, and it was gradually phased out over the end of the 20thst century. As final nail in the poor Sheridan's coffin, [[Herp|in their stupidity the US Army retired it during the 90's without a proper replacement]]. Projects like the RDF LT were launched and many companies opened private ventures. [https://www.flamesofwar.com/Default.aspx?tabid=79&ProductID=8989 The latter of which is now being introduced into the game]. Today the Army is holding a competition for a new Light Tank. With the big three (General Dynamics, BAE Systems and Raython) offering up their own platforms for the program as the Stryker based M1128 Mobile Gun System isn't up to the task. Insult to injury, when the Sheridan was retired from active service, the National Training Center picked up a couple and [[pretend|dressed them up as Soviet Bloc vehicles (T-72s, T80s, and BMPs)]] to help train US servicemen in identifying possible enemy tanks.  
Thus, with the end result buggier than an iPhone the Sheridans in Vietnam simply weren't issued any ATGMs, limiting them to chuck their caseless HE at footsloggers. The 152mm gun did have an antipersonnel flechette round available late in the war, and records of its use in Cambodia make it sound [[rape|highly effective]]. But, while the infantry loved the Sheridan for its direct-fire support, the lack of a working AT ammunition got them [[rape|REKT]] in turn when the northern commies sent proper MBT's into the dance. This proved to be the beginning of the end for the Sheridan, and it was gradually phased out over the end of the 20thst century. As final nail in the poor Sheridan's coffin, [[Herp|in their stupidity the US Army retired it during the 90's without a proper replacement]]. Projects like the RDF LT were launched and many companies opened private ventures. [https://www.flamesofwar.com/Default.aspx?tabid=79&ProductID=8989 The latter of which is now being introduced into the game]. Today the Army is holding a competition for a new Light Tank. With the big three (General Dynamics, BAE Systems and Raython) offering up their own platforms for the program as the Stryker based M1128 Mobile Gun System isn't up to the task. Insult to injury, when the Sheridan was retired from active service, the National Training Center picked up a couple and [[pretend|dressed them up as Soviet Bloc vehicles (T-72s, T80s, and BMPs)]] to help train US servicemen in identifying possible enemy tanks.  

Revision as of 16:54, 8 September 2021

Airborne!

"Always make the enemy think you know more than you really know."

– Gen. Phillip Sheridan

The M551 Sheridan was an American Light Tank Airborne Assault Vehicle that was rushed into service to meet the demand for armored vehicles in Vietnam. Unique for its time, the 152mm main gun was able to fire anti-tank guided missiles FROM THE BARREL. However, the missile option was never used in Vietnam and ultimately replaced with the more ubiquitous BGM-71 TOW missile launcher. Instead, the Sheridan was primarily an infantry support vehicle, using its low-velocity cannon to fire HE Shells.

In Team Yankee

The Stats
The Stats

The Sheridan is the only tank that you can take as part of the Huey Infantry Combat Team since it was the only tank you could throw out of the back of an airplane where the airborne needed it most.

The M81 152mm gun is an interesting weapons system. At close ranges (out to 16") it uses a HEAT shell with AT 21 and a firepower of 1+. Yes, you can one-shot T55s from the front, and with the brutal rule infantry and other units without an armour save have to reroll their successful saves. Unfortunately, you only have a ROF of 1 when moving or halted, although with a Stabilizer, you don't get +1 to hit for moving. For ranges in excess of 16" (because you physically cannot shoot it less than that), you can use the MGM51 Shillelagh (Shill-lay-lee) Guided Missile. The Shillelagh is an AT 22, firepower 3+ missile that can smack targets out to 48" away. However, you can't fire the Shillelagh on the move.

Now since the difference between AT is negligible, and the firepower disparity is the difference between killing a target 2/3rds of the time and killing it every time, you might wonder why would you ever use the Shillelagh. Well, it mostly comes down to defences. The M551 only has a front armour of 4, so basically, any AT weapon is going to cut right through it like it wasn't even there, and 30mm autocannons from the BMP-2 and the Scimitar will shred you, but 4 armor might suffice against NATO IFVs in field exercises. However, you should keep the enemy at an arm's length and use concealment to avoid taking fire: it might be stronger than an M113 but it dies when tanks look at it funny. This method will extend the lifetime of your Sheridan, but you can't utilize the HEAT shell.

You also get a pair of MGs for dealing with infantry, of which the .50cal can be used for air defense.

The M551 Sheridan is the cheapest NATO tank weighing in at only 2 points per vehicle and can be taken in platoons ranging from 2 to 5 tanks.

IRL

EAT THIS IVAN!

God, where to begin with this one? The M551 was a cursed design on so many levels it becomes funny so tragic it is...

As with most such cases, one has to look to the immediate post-WWII and the Korea War to see where it all started. During that period, the US Army was fielding the M41 Walker Bulldog as a light tank. A compromise between mobility and firepower, it was fast for a vehicle of its size and had good firepower for a light tank. Except the M41 wasn't exactly light: it was about the same size and weight as a WWII medium tank. It was too big for reconnaissance and too heavy for air drops, and would drain its fuel tank dry in less than 100 miles. All in all, it was a complete failure as a light tank and just barely adequate for frontline combat.

Fast-forward to the early sixties: the Army is pushing for a successor to the M41. This time, they want a proper LIGHT tank for doing light tank duties, and there's a promising prototype, the T92... And then those goddamn Red bastards have to come and ruin the day as they start fielding air-droppable, amphibious and ATGM-equipped 'light tank' designs. The Army saw, took duly note, and decided that whatever the Reds had; they had to have too! Exit the T92, as while it can be made air-droppable it cannot easily made to be amphibious, and the Army adamantly believed their light tank needed to do both to oppose those dirty commies.

This however got them into a pinch: having switched to the MBT doctrine and already pouring massive budget in the MBT-70 project (another can of worms best left opened for another day and place), the Army simply could not ask for more budget for yet another tank. So they elegantly reclassified the new project as an "Armored Reconnaissance/Airborne Assault Vehicle" instead, and pushed it through with the alluring sales pitch the vehicle would be lightweight, amphibious, air-droppable, and able to use both state-of-the-art caseless munitions and ATGMs. In theory, the perfect lightweight jack-of-all-trades to support the bigger full-fledged tanks currently in development.

Sadly enough, in practice the Sheridan turned out to be a complete and utter master-of-none. It was air-droppable and amphibious, yes, and its light structure made it less at risk to bog down or throw tracks than his bigger M48 and M60 cousins. But for the rest. Nothing. Worked. As. Intended! The worst offender was the Shillelagh ATGM: the Army's performance demands from Ford Aerospace for the missile circa 1963 were audacious--too audacious for 1960s or 1970s technology, not if it was going to be mass produced. Part of the problem was that due to limitations of the guidance system, designed in the 1960s, a Shillelagh ATGM could not be fired at closer than 730 meters, held by some to be greater than the distance to which the main gun could be fired with any accuracy. It took that long to stabilize and begin accepting guidance input from the gunner. Worse, the tank might have been air-droppable but the ATGM's themselves weren't, as the solid rocket fuel tended to crack during drop testing. To compound problems further, the 152mm gun/launcher was such a high caliber for the Sheridan's overall size that every time it fired the vehicle bucked backward and all the fucking electronics had to go through a full reboot, making switching from HE shells to ATGM's a pain. (It is sad/hilarious that of the over 80.000 produced ATGM's, no more than a dozen were ever fired at a real enemy over the entire lifespan of the M551.)

Thus, with the end result buggier than an iPhone the Sheridans in Vietnam simply weren't issued any ATGMs, limiting them to chuck their caseless HE at footsloggers. The 152mm gun did have an antipersonnel flechette round available late in the war, and records of its use in Cambodia make it sound highly effective. But, while the infantry loved the Sheridan for its direct-fire support, the lack of a working AT ammunition got them REKT in turn when the northern commies sent proper MBT's into the dance. This proved to be the beginning of the end for the Sheridan, and it was gradually phased out over the end of the 20thst century. As final nail in the poor Sheridan's coffin, in their stupidity the US Army retired it during the 90's without a proper replacement. Projects like the RDF LT were launched and many companies opened private ventures. The latter of which is now being introduced into the game. Today the Army is holding a competition for a new Light Tank. With the big three (General Dynamics, BAE Systems and Raython) offering up their own platforms for the program as the Stryker based M1128 Mobile Gun System isn't up to the task. Insult to injury, when the Sheridan was retired from active service, the National Training Center picked up a couple and dressed them up as Soviet Bloc vehicles (T-72s, T80s, and BMPs) to help train US servicemen in identifying possible enemy tanks.

US Forces in Team Yankee
Tanks: M1 Abrams - M60 Patton - M551 Sheridan - RDF/LT
Transports: M113 Armored Personnel Carrier - UH-1 Huey - AAVP7 - Bradley Fighting Vehicle - Pickup Trucks
Troops: US Mech Platoon - Marine Rifle Platoon - Huey Rifle Platoon - HMMWV Machine Gun Platoon - Light Motor Infantry Platoon - Irregular Militia Group
Artillery: M106 Heavy Mortar Carrier - M109 Howitzer - LAV-M - M270 MLRS
Anti-Aircraft: M163 VADS - M48 Chaparral - M247 Sergeant York - HMMWV SAM
Tank Hunters: M901 ITV - HMMWV-TOW - LAV-AT
Recon: M113 FIST- M113 Scout Section - HMMWV Scout Section - LAV-25 - Bradley Fighting Vehicle
Aircraft: A-10 Warthog - AV-8 Harrier - AH-1 Cobra Attack Helicopter - AH-64 Apache Attack Helicopter