Grimdark: Difference between revisions

From 2d4chan
Jump to navigation Jump to search
1d4chan>Commissar Woods
No edit summary
1d4chan>Commissar Woods
mNo edit summary
Line 156: Line 156:
[[Dark Eldar|A once great species]] whom, after their unholy and insidious demise will, out of their hatred for Slaanesh, continue (with oblivious glee) to empower him in order to save themselves.
[[Dark Eldar|A once great species]] whom, after their unholy and insidious demise will, out of their hatred for Slaanesh, continue (with oblivious glee) to empower him in order to save themselves.


[[Orks|A race of creatures who, despite being the people with the brightest potential; near mastery over the psychic, near natural physical perfection and almost limitless numbers from their highly successful methods of reproduction, are restricted by an unsuitable lust for battle which drives each to idiocy, hopeless of advancing beyond simple barbarians.
[[Orks|A race of creatures]] who, despite being the people with the brightest potential; near mastery over the psychic, near natural physical perfection and almost limitless numbers from their highly successful methods of reproduction, are restricted by an unsuitable lust for battle which drives each to idiocy, hopeless of advancing beyond simple barbarians.


[[Necron|An ancient people]] whom, were so envious of their neighbors power that they were ready to cripple the entire galaxy just to gain petty superiority. A superiority neutered by their unwitting transformation into metaphorical and literal automatons; mindless machines who bar few care nothing of their past and seek only one thing: war.
[[Necron|An ancient people]] whom, were so envious of their neighbors power that they were ready to cripple the entire galaxy just to gain petty superiority. A superiority neutered by their unwitting transformation into metaphorical and literal automatons; mindless machines who bar few care nothing of their past and seek only one thing: war.

Revision as of 16:26, 17 July 2016

It's totally the opposite of this.
Inspector Gadget, reimagined with a grimdark feel.
Grimdark versions of the TMNT. Their mentor is a Scaven.

" They say, Evil prevails when good men fail to act. What they ought to say is, Evil prevails."
-Yuri Orlov

Grimdark is an adjective derived from the tagline for Warhammer 40k, which states that "In the grim darkness of the far future, there is only war." It is generally used to describe a dilapidated, dystopian "crapsack world" setting which it would really suck to live in, as say Somalia, Venezuela, North Korea, or the setting of Warhammer 40k itself (in fairness, this is because the published material primarily focuses on war and cults and other horrible things. There are supposed to be many pleasant and peaceful worlds and sectors in the Imperium, but they are mostly ignored as they are boring -- and when they DO appear in lore or fluff, they're usually to go from "0 problems" to "totally fucked", very quickly. Unless, of course, we're talking about planets in the Macragge system. It can also be used to describe artwork that has a grimdark feel, even if the setting itself would not normally be considered grim or dark, or something sinister or uncommonly threatening/intimidating in real-life.

Depending on your own personal tolerances for grim darkness of course, it can be taken to the extreme, just like with all descriptive traits. There is a point in which it becomes more ridiculous than anything else, because everything is indefeasibly tragic all the time - the term for this being grimderp, which is explained further below.

This is an accusation often leveled at Warhammer itself, and leads some to rail against "Grimdark" as a whole, decrying the concept as ridiculous attempts at edginess (typically by teenagers), and using the expression to refer solely to such over-the-top settings in a strictly pejorative manner. Others actually embrace this ridiculousness and run with it (including Warhammer 40K itself, due to being a much more obviously comedic setting in early editions), insisting that the detractors who take it seriously (or the creators who take it seriously) are making a mistake. Some people embrace the grimdarkness and mix it up with some humor (like painting Necrons with bright colors to make them look like eatable candy figurines), especially if they are Ork players. But the schism between taking Warhammer's grimdarkness seriously or not is mostly visible with races such as the Tau, who are noticeably less grimdark than most of the other races and are either loved or absolutely hated for it (when they're not hated for being overpowered as shit). Meanwhile, another sizable percentage instead postulate that Grimdarkness lends greater moral and ethical complexity to a setting, based on the fallacy that darkness always equals depth). Such people usually cite the works of Dan Abnett and many other Warhammer 40K writers to lend credence to such suppositions; these people are clearly ignoring that fact that most writers tone the grimdark WAY down. What, you didn't think the fact that the Imperium being an effective government, civilians having normal happy lives on par with the Scandinavians, Commissars who never *BLAM* their troops was odd?. Needless to say, grimdark is a rather polarizing subject whose discussion often leaves little room for a middle ground.

Speaking of, the polar opposite of grimdark is Noblebright, a deliberate inversion of grim and dark nature where honor, chivalry, happiness and high adventure rule the day, as opposed to dying in a ditch from a supernatural plague as you run out of potable water and can no longer wait for the logistics department to process your dead comrades into something slightly more palatable before you start eating them. Oh, and being *BLAM*ed by a Commissar for even starting to look a little sad from these thoughts.

Common grimdark themes

Just like in real life.

Stuff considered Grimdark

A world where the only way to beat grimdark is by introducing something even grimmer and darker
  • Warhammer 40,000 (Naturally).
  • Warhammer Fantasy Battle, but less than you'd think.
  • Dwarf Fortress.
  • End of War.
  • Most of Shakespeare's iconic plays, especially Macbeth and Hamlet.
  • 1984.
  • Paranoia (though used for parodying 1984).
  • The majority of the tragedy genre of stories.
  • RIFTS.
  • Blame!.
  • Berserk.
  • Kingdom Death(Makes 40k's setting seem pleasant and cheerful).
  • Eastenders (especially at Christmas).
  • Grimdark Songwriting.
  • Don't Rest Your Head.
  • SLA Industries.
  • World of Darkness.
  • CthulhuTech.
  • Call of Cthulhu.
  • Everything from H.P Lovecraft and the Cthulhu Mythos.
  • Playing mortals in Exalted.
  • Neon Genesis Evangelion. Especially the movie.
  • Midnight setting for D&D.
  • FATAL.
  • Rebecca Black.
  • I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream: The Game (just the title itself should give you a clue on how horrorific the game is.The book is even worse).
  • The Medieval Dark Ages where Warhammer 40000 was originally based on. If you disregard China that is.
  • The Witcher (racism, genocides, dozens of monsters that want to eat Your face whenever You enter the random forest. Or cave. Or ruins. The third installment of the video game adaptation even features a medieval Hitler running the Witch Hunters, a fanatical order of racist scumbags dedicated to wiping out both mages and non-humans in the name of the Eternal Fire).
  • Dark Souls (the entire world is dying. That is all you should probably need to know. If you want to be specifics, then in the setting, most of the population are undead, you die constantly, and you have to fight enemies larger and filthier than you are, including a naked bitch with a spider vagina. Also, FAKE TITS. Again: one of those series that makes WH40K look like a sweet stroll in the park in comparison).
  • Gears of War (decades of civil war, genocide and weapons of mass destruction has turned your home planet into a quasi-dead world. The human race is close to extinction, women are reduced to birthing machines, your government is an uncaring fascist scumbag, the weather is often rain consisting of razor sharp ice crystals that could cut you into ribbons, you're fighting a never-ending war with genocidal monsters from the underground and the world is literally dying from super fuel.)
  • Hellgate London.
  • Most of David Bowie's songs about 1990.
  • The first two Hellraiser movies and also Event Horizon.
  • Cyberpunk 2020.
  • Hellsing... just all of Hellsing...
  • Bioshock (as well as Bioshock Infinite, though it comes hidden behind a smiling facade of barbershop singing and the Fourth of July).
  • Anything from the Xeelee Sequence.
    • The Interim Coalition of Governance for example, is such a grim-ridden shit-hole that they make the Imperium of Man look like pussies filled with sun-shine and rainbows in comparison. In fact, they are so Grimdark, that they would make even the Adeptus Custodes shit themselves in collateral fear. In fact, despite achieving time travel, conquering the entire Galaxy Universe through xenocide that would make the Necrons look like children and shooting Neutron Stars at .99c at the speed of light. The ICoG is still a minor nuisance compared to the scale between the Xeelee and their enemies, the Photino Birds. If anything, Stephen Baxter was able to construct the insignificance and petty malevolence of Man in a few books better than GeeDubs more questionable authors did in decades. tl;dr the IoM wishes they would be as cool as the ICoG.
  • North Korea which is essentially "Real Life Oceania".
  • The Goon comic series by Eric Powell (because circus hillbillies, werewolves with midget hand phobias, and the Zombie Priest are the least of it all).
  • [1]Children of men: a future where humans are no longer fertile and going extinct, and then someone finds a pregnant woman and nearly everyone in the world fights over her.
  • A Song of Ice and Fire: Good guys screw up monumentally or never win, the only people who get ahead are amorally manipulative assholes and everyone is going to be massacred and enslaved by the evil ice elf necromancers in the end. And if they somehow survive, then another war for the Iron Throne will happen after the winner gets their revenge-boner satisfied and later, their kids would need to clean up the wankstains.
  • Dishonored - Grimdark, and steampunk. Only in the "Kill fucking everyone" ending though.
  • X-Com (The remake, and the original, as a parody of the G.I. Joe Badass stereo type, you're struggling with funding and even your gods in human form, some of whom make certain chapters of Astartes weep, can get fucked over by Sectoids!)
  • Madoka Magica.
  • Adventure Time's backstory.
  • Path of Exile.
  • Pokemon Tabletop Adventures (optionally).
  • Spec Ops: The Line (Because no one felt like a hero after all this).
  • Original fairy tales ("Hansel and Gretel", for example).
  • Alien (as in the biomechanical, parasitic, acid-blooded brainchild of Ridley Scott and the late H.R. Giger).
  • Halo (the setting of Halo is one grand scale of a Cosmic Horror Story centered around absolute hopelessness and bleakness of a Universe governed by hyper malevolent gods. Our good guys, the UNSC? Well it's a semi-authoritarian 'Big Brother is Watching You', fascistic style government that have no qualms in dumping a barrage of nukes on a civilian population if rebellion is sighted. The UNSC also have no problems dicking over their only alien 'friends' just so it could benefit humanity, while also being bogged down in a political quagmire. The Covenant are much, much worse, while anything from the Forerunner trilogy is just a high concoction of Nightmare Fuel inside a depressing milkshake. Oh, and the hero of the setting, Master Chief? No matter how many victories he achieves, he is always losing his friends and loved ones.)
  • Battletech.
  • Attack on Titan (You cannot win, ever. And if you do, you've probably lost all your friends, who've been eaten by giant freaky humans, who don't even need food. Yeeeah).
  • Metro series (both the books and games, but mostly in the books, where the last known humans are hiding in underground subway tunnels, and when they're not trying to finish each other off, they are fighting endless hordes of mutants and other, much worse things. Also, let's not forget that if you're one of the stalkers, the few brave ones that head to the surface to loot anything they can find, you risk being eaten by flying daemons. Hell, it even has the same "abandon all hope" vibe in the intro, just like 40k. And that is just the tip of the iceberg.)
  • Madness combat - no regret, no remorse, no reason, only madness.
  • LISA the RPG.
  • The Darkness videogames.
  • The first two Hyperion books.
  • Elfen Lied (where the next step of the evolution of mankind is a group schizoprenic homicidal mutant girls with invisible tentacle hands and a hair-trigger temper who will either kill you in the worst way possible or else infect you with their gene to increase their numbers.)
  • Most of Stephen King's works.
  • Crossed (Most of the world is dead or turned into murder-raping sadists á la the Reavers from Firefly. Showing any courage will get you killed or turned into one of the aforementioned murder-rapists, and there are survivors that are just as fucked up as the infectees.)
  • S.T.A.L.K.E.R. (You travel in a desolate landscape, filled with mutants in all the horrific varieties, failed science projects (curtesy of the USSR), anomalies that you often can't see and kill you instantly and a lot of renegades/bandits/fanatics/zombies. Your gear breaks all the time, resources are scarce and your goal is to get to the highly dangerous Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant. Why is the Nuclear Power Plant dangerous? Because it blew the fuck up back in the 80's (in real life, no less) and is protected by lots of fanatics with the best gear you can get. If you make it through that hellish place that is The Zone, you'll most likely get one of the 5 really grimdark endings, and if you payed a lot of attention to certain seemingly useless items along the way, you may get one of the other two endings which are also grimdark. The rest of the world also largely ignores what's happening inside The Zone, aside from a few scientists that study the deadly phenomena and the Ukrainian military that maintains a cordon around The Zone so the nasty stuff doesn't get out.)
  • The Slenderman Mythos (HE ALWAYS WATCHES).
  • The Old Testament.
  • Dante's Inferno. For exemple : sins of Greed and Glutony are punished by being eaten alive by Cerberus, who then proceed in transforming ye corpse into slowly regenerating shit mud ; after being whole again, thou art eaten while trying to flee in despair, and it start anew. For ever. Because some old dude called Minos decided so.
  • The F.E.A.R. series (even the third vanilla-by-comparison game is fucked up).
  • Total War: Attila (Unlike the previous titles in Total War, which were about your faction's rise to power from small backwater city/tribe/country into a mighty empire able to boss around its neighbors into doing your bidding, this one is more or less about the decline of your faction as you desperately try to survive the onslaught of the Huns, who's sole purpose in the game is to worship Tengri by burning, pillaging, and raping their way through the known world. Particularly if you are the Romans. Winning is defined by being the last guy standing who gets to clean up the rubble and dead bodies, trying to rebuild their world after Attila destroyed it. Seriously, even the music sounds depressing and foreboding as fuck.)
  • Darkest Dungeon.
  • The Day After, and its worse Brit counterpart, Threads.
  • Lord Of War. The worst is that it's based on real events.
  • SCP universe.Why do you ask? because above all Secure. Contain. Protect.
  • Shisha no Teikoku, the Empire of Corpses. Steampunk, Grimdark, Zombies, Cross-References and Conspiracies everywhere. It has even become possible to resurect the dead, giving them their soul and intelligence back, but only 2 characters profit from it in the end, while everyone else stays a slave.

Grimderp

Grimderp is what happens when a writer takes Grimdark so far that it goes DERP. The writer puts something in that makes the setting more Grimdark but it's reliant on a party/parties being epicly stupid or caused by a lack of forethought on the implications of how the element interacts with the world.

  • Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons - A fanfiction about magical ponies so grim, dark, and derp that it would almost be comical if it wasn't so fucking horrifying. With characters that get shit on (both figuratively and literally) more than the Lamenters, and with a world so bleak (and missing the point of Fallout, FiM, and the original Fallout Equestria) that an heroing seems like WOULD ACTUALLY BE the happiest ending (Assuming it will end, it probably never will as long as there's enough cybernetics to keep rebuilding the constantly-dying protagonist) HOLY SHIT IT ACTUALLY ENDED!
  • Speaking of fanfics, 90% of all grimdark fics are grimderp since writers are under the impression that just making things Dark makes it good writing. There are exceptions, but they are rare, because Sturgeon's Law is a thing. On the flip side, however, certain examples have reached the apotheosis of Grimderp and become gut-bustingly hilarious.
  • Many long-runner grimdark works will become this sooner or later, due to people getting bored as they feel nothing ever goes anywhere and stop rooting for the character since there's no point. See the above two-million-word-long post-apocalyptic pony fanfic.
  • Warhammer 40,000 gets called-out as this by some. Certainly it's a valid criticism of certain parts, but as we said earlier, you could argue about what is and is not grimderp in 40k for weeks without conclusion. For example, the Imperium is excessively self-destructive and tyrannical to its own people, but in the hands of a good writer, its meant to underline how corrupt and desperate the Imperium has become without the Emperor's guidance, and how even those who are neither incompetent nor malicious still have to make brutally difficult choices. In the hands of a lesser writer, it's unnecessary evil purely for the sake of evil. We should call our next book "Darkness of Darkest Dark!"
  • Jeph Loeb's run on Ultimate Marvel: people dying brutally (most well known being Wasp getting eaten by the Blob) and completely gratuitously (Dr. Strange is killed the one page he shows up on and is completely forgotten afterwards), lore rape worst than anything Ward ever did (the heroic Pyro is now a rapist version of the mainline Marvel Pyro with no explanation, Thor going from new age hippie to mainline-style viking with no explanation... at least that last one is kinda cool). Overall it was so bad it effectively made the Ultimate Marvel universe (with the exception of Spider-Man and his cast) completely unusable. Small wonder that years later, Marvel thought smashing it and the main Marvel universe together would be a good idea.
  • Most "dark" anime/manga tend to be more or less Grimderp, as attempts to attract mature audiences ends in gratuitous blood, sex wuthout consquence and violence. Not that different from the West, really. Examples include Akame Ga Kiru, also known to non-weeaboos as "that Kill la Kill-looking animu that keeps popping up on Netflix", and Koutetsujou no Kabaneri, which is similar to Attack on Titan, except it's set in Japan, where people are hiding behind walls and communicate with each others using trains to travel from town to town, and trades the giants and horses for guns and zombies.
    • The samurai depicted in the latter setting are terrible in regards to combat; despite the zombies requiring close range to do their damage, they don't even bother with the most baseline of armor, and can't even wield their swords properly; sure, they do check bodies prior to entering a town, but not while traveling, and sometimes, while the town is under attack and the walls are breached, they will panick and try to check before allowing the train to depart, thus ending up being under attack while without cover and surrounded by screaming humans about to turn into potential zombies. The antagonist, Amatori Biba, despite the immense amount of respect and followers they've gathered, is an absolute failure AND wanted for crimes against humanity, being a pretentious Che Guevara wannabe with pink hair and wielder of an ugly sabre (that actually performs strangely well as a piercing weapon, despite it's unrealistic design). His following exists despite of the fact that he can't even grasp the basics of warfare and its ethics, deciding that children are somehow cowards for not being able to fight off murderous creatures who run through trained adult fighters with ease (usually by getting the drop on them). He also thinks destroying one's own resources and castles is a viable strategy. And YET, the main protagonist has found not one, but TWO miracle solutions that would allow mankind to fight back against the zombie plague... but no one will listen to him, especially not his formerly allied Antagonist, both because of the above and because of course they wouldn't, it's grimderp GRIMDARK.
      • Ironically, though gods of death and hell are common througout the world, Ancient Shintoism had the only known anti-zombies deities, Kukuri hime no kami, a goddess of purification, whose followers used one of the most insane form of burial, the Japanese Crouched Burial 屈葬 : binding the corpse with ropes, placing a big stone on the chest and burying it (coffins are an extra option). Through all the Jomon period it was the most common form of burial, and never went completely out of date through all the medieval period, a time where she was linked with the buddhist deity of Mercy, Kanzeon, under the Shinbutsu Shugo doctrine. Hence, Japan invented the Zombie concept, while at the same time preventing any Undead invasion to overtake the still living Japanese through millenias. Also, since the Meiji period, the cult of Kukuri-hime has considerably declined, despite that one might think pop culture would be interested by an ancient Anti-Zombie Sado-Masochist Japanese Princess Goddess (also, all Japanese gods ar per default, gods of Ice Bucket challenge and Alcoolic parties, so she is also a drunk bitch that will pour down well water buckets on your head to make you Repent and then tie you up anyway when you die). Yet, looks like in this setting, it was not enough to ward off a zombie plague forever... Double Grimdark !

Grim Tragedy

Naturally in a universe such as 40k, the Grimdarkness of the setting would mean nothing if not tied into the ironic tragedy of the lore. This includes:

A species whom, are so afraid of the dauntless perils of Chaos, will brutally harass and execute entire populations out of mere suspicion to stop the spread of ruin while indirectly in doing so strengthening those who seek to destroy them (Including Chaos)

A once great species whom, after their unholy and insidious demise will, out of their hatred for Slaanesh, continue (with oblivious glee) to empower him in order to save themselves.

A race of creatures who, despite being the people with the brightest potential; near mastery over the psychic, near natural physical perfection and almost limitless numbers from their highly successful methods of reproduction, are restricted by an unsuitable lust for battle which drives each to idiocy, hopeless of advancing beyond simple barbarians.

An ancient people whom, were so envious of their neighbors power that they were ready to cripple the entire galaxy just to gain petty superiority. A superiority neutered by their unwitting transformation into metaphorical and literal automatons; mindless machines who bar few care nothing of their past and seek only one thing: war.

A newborn race, who innocently believes that there can be peace and acknowledgement among the each others but unfortunately itself, with the sinister ways it is using, hoping that it is for something better it is slowly, but steadily falls into the decadance the other species fall themselves, showing not olny that anyone, no matter his intentions, can be corrupted but also how kind can some beings could have been but instead choose damnation and despair....

That, despite hundreds of thousands of years of knowing nothing but only war, these peoples are woefully unprepared for what is to come. No matter how many regiments can be raised or Craftworlds restored, what is out there is all consuming, diabolical and numberless...

See also

External Links

Retrieved from "http://23.235.193.55/mediawiki/index.php?title=Grimdark&oldid=263123"